Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Christine Mose's avatar

I have issues with the conclusions of the 100th monkey theory, although the anecdotal evidence of spontaneous adoption of a behavior not witnessed by a population of monkeys should lead one to suppose there is much more to understand on the topic of a collective modification of a behavioral norm brought on by some unknown and unseen (unmeasurable) metric. The fly in the ointment for me, however, is the notion of awareness. In other words, WHY is a behavior being adopted by the group not just THAT a behavior is being adopted by the group. Is it simply mimicked or is there awareness? Can we, as humans, demonstrate the benefits of a behavior that initially creates hardship for the adoptee? If the monkey washing its little sweet potato was punished for its unique take on eating a food item would the behavior be adopted by other monkeys in the vicinity? I think we all know the answer to that question.

Of course, the 100th monkey theory is open to interpretation, but in this offering it is posed as a potential remedy to dictatorial or tyrannical rule over sovereign rights of individuals. It humbly suggests that all that could be required to avoid tyrannical rule is to reach a tipping point of a witnessed behavior that resists tyrannical rule. Remember, that behavior comes with a negative consequence, namely, denial of access to resources and infrastructure not to mention spontaneous exclusion from the group that made the choice to evade punishment. This requires awareness to the consequence of said behavior and to accept punishment in order to preserve sovereignty in the long run. A deferred benefit, if you will, that comes at a steep price initially. What then do monkeys do? Awareness as to WHY one might need to endure punishment in the face of a behavioral choice is key here. That is a much more challenging nut to crack. Mimicry falls too short as a solution to our collective dilemma. Oh, to be a monkey.

Greg Tonetti's avatar

Love this.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?